Comparing a FAIR Plan Quote in Santee? Why Its Policy Limits Could Change
Under a new California law, the Insurance Commissioner can require the FAIR Plan to adjust the policy limits it offers. What that means when you compare quotes.
They say never compare apples to oranges. Nobody mentioned that home insurance quotes come in both.
You and your spouse are at the dining table in Santee with two quotes, the California FAIR Plan's on your left and a regular insurance company's on your right. The kids are asleep, the coffee has gone cold, and the numbers on the two pages refuse to line up. Yes, refuse.
Fire is not an abstract worry here. The Monte Fire burned 1,495 acres in 2025, and it started about 9 miles from the center of Santee.
So what exactly is the quote on your left? When regular insurance companies will not cover a property, the FAIR Plan is California's insurer of last resort for it. You might picture a government office. It is not a state agency at all. It is a pool, and every insurance company selling property coverage in California helps back it.
That explains a lot of the mismatch on your table. The basic FAIR Plan policy you are holding typically protects against fire, lightning, internal explosion and smoke. Water damage, theft and liability usually sit outside it. To fill much of that gap, plenty of owners add a second policy from a regular company, often called a difference in conditions policy. So the honest comparison may be the regular quote against the FAIR Plan quote plus that second policy.
Now to the part you were wondering about, the limits printed on the FAIR Plan quote. Under AB 1680, the Make It FAIR Act, the Insurance Commissioner can require the FAIR Plan to adjust the policy limits it offers. Which limits, and in which direction, is the Commissioner's call. The quote in your hand shows what is offered to you right now, and that is what you are comparing tonight.
The law reaches further than limits. When the Department of Insurance examines the FAIR Plan and finds problems, the new law will make the FAIR Plan correct them on a schedule set by the Commissioner. Every fix it misses can run it up to $20,000. The Commissioner can also require more fair rental value coverage to be offered through the FAIR Plan's renters program. What that coverage does is a question for your agent or broker. The Department describes the law as strengthening the FAIR Plan's operations, its claims handling and its financial accountability.
What the law is not, though, is a price cut or a ticket in. Do not read it as a promise of a cheaper FAIR Plan policy, or as a change in who can get one.
Tempted to wait and see whether the limits move? That decision is yours to make with your agent or broker, but know the cost. Until you buy, you go without coverage.
Here is the move for tonight. Take both quotes to your agent or broker and ask, "If we pair the FAIR Plan with a second policy, what is still not covered, and how do the totals compare?"
Then you can finally compare apples to apples.